I've been doing Project Life this year since about April. I really love the process of picking out the photos and tucking my memorabilia into the pockets in the protectors. You can see all my Project Life related posts
on my blog here.
For 2012 I am planning on doing Project Life with the physical kit again, even though I've been a digi-scrapper for years. I have many reasons, but the main one is I do tuck a lot of physical memorabilia into the pockets each week, and I can't do that digitally. Second reason is I love that when friends or family come over, I can just show them my book. They can see all our life documentation just sitting on the coffee table. One digi PL product that I AM planning on purchasing is the 3x4 journaling cards. The reason is I sometimes type my journaling on the computer in Photoshop, then print them out onto the physical PL journaling cards. If I have the digital versions as a template, I will know for sure which design areas to avoid typing onto. My printouts onto my physical PL journal cards will be even better now!
As for the plastics... I do have a a bunch of different configurations of We R Memory Keepers 12x12 page protectors that I purchased this year already. But the Becky Higgins Design A protectors are a must-have for this project if you want to use the core kit. Design A is what I find I use the most, as the default page protector for my PL this year. The reason is, the 3x4 journal cards fit in there. I bought the large pack of Design A for 2012. I love using the 3x4 journaling cards and the Design A page protector is the only one that fits 8 of those journaling cards across the week. That's my default configuration for my weekly pages. If I have extra photos or memorabilia, I will use another one of my various page protectors to supplement. But I never stray from Design A. Also because most of my photos are landscape-oriented and not portrait-oriented.
As for photo printing, I have two strategies. If you actually are able to keep up with PL weekly, then you really do need a printer at home to print the photos, it's the easiest and most convenient. But if you fall behind at all, it will become a big chore to print them all out at home. When I fall behind and need to print 3-4 weeks of photos that I picked out, I will just upload them all and pick up at Costco.
Those are my main thoughts on doing PL this year. Plan to catch up this Thanksgiving weekend. I'll also be doing a blog post soon on why I'm still going to do PL with the physical products, and how the digi products could complement that.